We went over 50 customer reviews we were able to find on the internet. Overall more than 85% of the buyers seemed really pleased with their purchase. The Garrett At max got a rating of 4,4 out of 5 stars.
The top positive review was this one :
There’s a lot of youtube reviews that do the unit justice, so I’ll keep this short. Like a lot of guys, I upgraded from the AT Pro. Simply put, the Max works great on land and fresh water. The wireless headphones are a big improvement over the AT Pro. The upgraded grip is nice, but I didn’t mind the foam grip on the Pro. Sensitivity is definitely improved, you’ll find more goodies in hunted out areas. The metal disc is great and is easy to tell most metal junk like nails, and even most metal bottle caps from a coin. FINALLY, an all metal mode, this is where the Max really shines. If you’re upgrading from the Pro, keep in mind the Max has only Pro tones. That’s a good thing for a serious detectorist, but maybe not for a noob. My one gripe? Like most others, I could not get it to work in salt water or wet salt water sand. Single freq VLF detectors like the Garrett AT series just don’t work well in salt water like pulse and multi-frequency detectors do.
The top critical review was the following:
Having had an AT Pro the last 3 years, I was super excited about the new features of the AT Max – particularly the additional depth in the All Metal Mode. What has quickly become apparent, however, is that All Metal is essentially useless (for me) in all but the least trashy locales. As the name implies, it picks up all metal, including foil, can slaw, rusty iron, bottle tops. To be expected when there is no discrimination. The challenge with that is you really can’t tell what’s what in this mode. The tone is the same for everything, and the VDI #’s are very misleading/unreliable – particularly the deeper the object. There’s always a learning curve with every new machine, but I’ve used it for a couple months now and I’ve already dug more trash with it than I did most of last year with the Pro.
Without All Metal Mode, you basically have an AT Pro – or a hybrid of the Pro and the AT Gold – with a few new whizzbangs. Backlight, volume control, wireless headphone. All very nice features. But they could have just as easily added that to the Pro or Gold and called it done.
What I like about it:
– wireless headphones
– volume control
What I don’t like about it:
– lack of tone differentiation in All Metal Mode
– runs no deeper than my AT Pro in every mode other than All Metal
– goes through batteries faster – likely due to the backlight feature, and possibly the wireless
– tones are different than with the Pro. With the Pro, I can usually tell what something is, based on the sound and the VDI. I’m expecting this will get better with more time on the machine.